The season opens with a suburbian scene. A women seems to be crying in front of a mirror. She then goes on to host a book club meeting, when suddenly the floor starts shaking and they all rush outside. Out of the houses of this small community, people come rushing out – among them are Ethan, the man who infiltrated the middle section survivors’ camp, as well as the man who pretended to be Henry Gale. The look up to the sky and see a plane breaking apart and falling. The scene was taking place on the Island, with the Others, all along. The fake Henry Gale is in command, and he orders Ethan and Goodwin to have a look at the two crash sites and, if there are survivors, go undercover and send back a list of the people after three days.
Jack, Kate, and Sawyer, who have been taken by the Others, start coming to. All of them seem to have received an injection in their arm. Jack is imprisoned in a dark, cold cell. The woman from the book club talks to him and introduces herself as Juliet. She talks to him calmly, and tries to get Jack to relax and allow her to bring some food to him, but he overpowers her and tries to break out. On the way, he encounters the fake Henry Gale, who tells him to not open the door he is trying to escape through. Jack ignores him and opens the door anyway. Water starts filling the corridor, and only with help from Juliet he manages to close the door again. They seem to be in some kind of aquarium for sharks and dolphins. Juliet says it’s called the Hydra. Jack also thinks he hears his father’s voice on the intercom, but Juliet tells him it has been broken for years.
Kate wakes up in a shower with Tom, the formerly bearded Other. She is forced to take a shower and wear a dress, then she meets with “Henry” at the beach for breakfast. He tells her that he did all this for her, in order for her to have something nice to hold on to, as the next two weeks would be very unpleasant for her.
Sawyer is thrown into an animal cage outside. A less than talkative boy in the second cage nearby helps him escape from his cage, but they are both captured, and the boy, called Karl by Tom, has to apologise to Sawyer for involving him. Later, Kate is thrown into the opposite cage, and Sawyer tries to comfort her.
Juliet presents Jack with a file the Others have on him, documenting every detail of every aspect of his life. In his flashbacks, Jack remembers his divorce from Sarah. He was ready to let her have anything she wanted, if only she told him who she was with now, so he could know why she left him. But Sarah does not want to tell him, as it doesn’t matter. Jack starts losing it, calling every number from Sarah’s phonebook, and even suspecting his father Christian of being with her when he finds his number. He confronts him in an Alcoholics Anonymous meeting, and is thrown in prison after attacking him. Sarah arrives to bail him out. She tells him that after 50 days of being sober, Christian has been drinking again, she was barely able to understand what he said when he called her about his son being in trouble. When Juliet asks Jack whether he would like to know anything about his file, in particular the information on his wife, he realises what his obsessive behavious has caused, and has only one question: whether she is happy now. Juliet says she is.
Juliet leaves the room and encounters the leader of the Others, the fake Henry Gale, and their conversation reveals not only that the two seem to have history, but also that his name is Ben.
Questions brought up in this episode
- Why was Juliet crying in front of the mirror?
- How can the Others maintain their suburbian lifestyle on the Island?
- Why does Ben want lists of the survivors?
- What were Kate, Jack, and Sawyer injected with?
- Where is the DHARMA station where the three are kept, and what was its purpose?
- Why are the next two weeks going to be unpleasant for Kate?
- Who is Karl? Why did the Others imprison him?
- How do the Others get all the information on the survivors?
Mysteries solved in this episode
- The man who claimed to be Henry Gale is in fact the leader of the Others, Ben. He sent Ethan and Goodwin undercover with the survivors in order to get lists of them.
- Jack, Kate, and Sawyer are held in or near a DHARMA station called the Hydra. It seems to have been used for zoological research as there are animal cages and an aquarium.